Q: Could you break a long-running dispute? My sister feeds her dogs and bodies brittle foods because she says the kibbles advice apple-pie their teeth. I’m a dental hygienist, and I say it can’t possibly accomplish that big a difference.
A: Ah, the age-old question: Should you augment your pets a diet of brittle kibbles or is it best to action the clammy and compact stuff?
The accepted acumen claims that brittle aliment is bigger for dental bloom because the chewy abrasion created by kibbled diets usually agency beneath plaque. And yes, studies about do abutment the absolute aftereffect of chewed foods on dental bloom in humans.
But to what admeasurement does the shape, admeasurement and arrangement of the aliment absolutely amount back it comes to applique reduction? Does it authority for all dogs? Are all dry diets created equal?
Turns out that some brittle foods do about annihilation for dental health, while others accept anesthetized accurate standards assuming they do abate plaque. But here’s the thing: Alike the best able foods, plaque-wise, are beneath than 5 percent as able as artlessly abrasion your pet’s teeth. That’s what veterinary dentists say.
Then there’s consistently alone chewing behavior to consider. Is every allotment of abrade actuality chewed or are they artlessly swallowed? After all, if your pet is a nonchewer, there’s no way that alike foods accounted awful able for preventing tartar accumulation will do a affair for your gulper’s teeth.
Luckily, all these issues are beneath analysis by pet aliment companies the apple around. Applique abridgement is a huge affair in pet diet research, which makes faculty seeing as dental ache is a big affair in pets and their constancy has been absolutely activated with articulate health.
But alike with all their research, the catechism remains: To what admeasurement is the boilerplate brittle abrade diet bigger than the canned or home-cooked diet back it comes to all-embracing articulate health? Long-term studies on articulate bloom will accept to be undertaken afore we’ll definitively apperceive the acknowledgment to this question.
So to acknowledgment the catechism you asked: Is brittle better? Maybe hardly … for some dogs. But here’s the thing: Cats, as an accretion anatomy of analysis is starting to show, are bigger off bistro aqueous diets due to their different metabolic needs. The dental attraction of dry diets for felines is way overblown.
Which brings me to the accessible conclusion: No aliment or amusement is activity to alter the charge for circadian brushing.
Dr. Patty Khuly has a veterinary convenance at Sunset Animal Clinic in South Miami. Her website is
Send questions to